A few months ago, as you may recall, I snuck into the end of one of my monthly posts about Felicity that I had come to the conclusion that I was in the One and Done camp. I probably said enough about it then to give you an idea of what I was thinking, but I've never been one to leave a topic alone unless I've beaten it completely into the ground, so I am going to write some more about what my thought process was/is in that subject area.
(Personally, I am FASCINATED by how people figure out whether and/or when to add to their family -- I really could talk about this sort of thing for days with anyone and everyone.)
As I mentioned before, we had been planning to have a second baby and we kind of...moved in that direction, if you will, beginning around Felicity's first birthday. In the late summer, I realized that every month I was breathing an enormous sigh of relief when I found that I wasn't pregnant. Around that time, I also had this crazy sort of waking-dream moment when I felt like an actual VOICE spoke in my ear in the middle of the night and said, "Don't have another baby." It was that clear.
As I weighed that thought and sat with it for a while, I realized that when I imagined being pregnant and again and having another baby, the first thing I felt wasn't joy or excitement. It was sadness. Sadness over having to divert some of my attention away from Felicity, having to share her with her hypothetical sibling, and losing the easy routine and rhythm we've settled into as a family of three. Also sadness over my feeling that we would be taking a big step back -- we'd gotten to the point where Felicity was becoming so easy to take places and so enjoyable to play with, and now we're within sight of a time when we can take her on longer flights and to more thrilling destinations without all of the Baby Travel Stress, and resetting our family to Newborn: Day One gave me less pleasure than angst, when I imagined what it would be like.
I also felt terribly anxious about the logistics of another baby, from small issues to large ones -- how we would fit in our two-bedroom apartment (or how we'd afford a bigger place), how I would juggle the schedules of two kids, how I'd navigate a double stroller in our little hallway, how our finances would change with two children and two sets of private school tuition, how we would afford the luxuries that we hardly have to think about now, like great vacations, classes for Felicity, and visits to family and friends who live far away. I also felt crushingly tired when I imagined the sleepless nights with a newborn combined with caring for an active, strong-minded first child.
All of these are concerns that I am sure a lot of people have, and the majority of people do just fine with two or more children. I don't think any of these things would hit us any harder than anyone else. Plenty of you out there have dealt with newborns -- newborn TWINS, even -- while caring for older children, and you've done it with grace and aplomb. I just don't have a lot of faith in my OWN ability to handle that without having a nervous breakdown or hugely neglecting some part of my life.
I think I was good at the newborn/infant stage with Felicity in a great many respects. I connected with her and loved her instantly, to the outer edges of the universe and back, and I settled quickly into a schedule and routine that worked well. I felt competent and happy much of the time when I was caring for her as a baby. Thank God, she was a decent sleeper who, in a reasonable amount of time, became an excellent sleeper, and she ate well and has been (knock on wood) very healthy.
AND YET.
Those first several months, when I had to wake up every couple of hours to feed her, and then I had to stand over her crib shushing her back to sleep and replacing her pacifier 8,000 times, all the while wishing to God I could just sleep STANDING UP because I thought I would throw up if I didn't rest -- those months pushed me to a Not Good Place.
I was, I am quite certain, VERY DIFFICULT to live with, because getting less than a solid eight (preferably nine) hours of sleep per night CRUSHES me in very short order, and the cumulative effect of it made me IMPOSSIBLE. I was cranky and hypercritical and fell to pieces at the drop of a hat. And of course, none of this was directed at Felicity -- by virtue of proximity it was primarily aimed at my long-suffering husband. He was a saint about it, but I felt awful that I was being this way, and even though I KNEW I was acting insane, I couldn't stop. Because, of course, on top of the lack of sleep, I was a roiling mass of post-partum hormones. They made me A WRECK. I thought when Joe wore Felicity in a carrier, he would smother her; I hyperventilated all the time over whether she was properly positioned/swaddled/aerated so as to erase the risk of SIDS; I thought everything everyone else did in relation to the baby was WRONG, ALL WRONG, oh just GIVE HER TO ME and let ME DO IT. Which of course made me martyrous, as the cherry on top of my So Fun To Be Around-ness, because I felt like I had to do EVERYTHING or WE WOULD ALL DIE, but at the same time couldn't someone HELP ME so I could SLEEP?
It was all quite magical.
Nursing, by the way, was also stressful for me, in part because it added to the feeling that I was the only one who could do anything for Felicity and I could never leave the house or go to the bathroom because I might have to feed the baby, but also because it was just...tiring and painful and chock full of its own special hormones. Oh, and it prevented me from losing weight (I AM CAVEWOMAN, MUST CONSERVE FOOD FOR BABY), which ALSO made me hate the way my body felt. Felicity was not a calm, easy nurser so there were times when I would be up at 2am, trying to feed her and she wouldn't latch on and I would be sobbing over her and she'd be screaming and MY GOD WHY DIDN'T I JUST GIVE HER A BOTTLE OF FORMULA AND MOVE ON?? When I weaned her, I went through a second wave of over-the-top anxiety and depression due to THAT hormone carnival funhouse, but after THAT things got SO. MUCH. EASIER. That was also when I went back to work and we hired J and I no longer had to be the over-the-crib-shusher at naptime, and whew, the worst was behind us.
The thing is, she WAS an easy baby, for the most part, and I know we got off pretty easily. (So then the anxious thought is, the second could be a DISASTER -- setting aside that I feel we dodged a lot of bullets by having things go smoothly and having a healthy child, and I worry that we'd be tempting fate by greedily going for another one.) But I have enjoyed everything since then a million times more, even though she is not always easygoing and can be frustratingly hard-headed. Yes, it was only about six months of really hard infant-times (well, after nine months of sciatica and several exciting encounters with preterm contractions, but since my pregnancy was also easy in the grand scheme, I feel like that hardly counts), so at times I berate myself for wanting to make a HUGE PERMANENT LIFE-ALTERING decision based on the possibility of things being REALLY DIFFICULT for a mere six months -- realistically, though, it would be much longer than that since toddler time is also hard and stressful in its own way (but of course it's also fun for a million reasons, too).
I guess what occurred to me back in September is that I have loved so much of this experience in a way that I can't put into words. But I don't feel overwhelmingly compelled to do it all over again.
Since the ultimate question is not necessarily whether you want a BABY, it's whether you want another CHILD, I guess I realized that I don't really want...either one. I DO want to be able to go back and visit baby and toddler Felicity at will; I am nostalgic from time to time about doing the butt-pats on her tiny diaper and the feeling of her fuzzy baby-head under my chin, to the point that I almost fly to pieces from wanting to hold that little body again and kiss those tiny lips a million times. But that's not enough for me to go for it because -- despite everything I just said above -- that time FLEW by, and it would FLY by with a second baby, too. It's ALL impermanent. We could have TWELVE babies and they would ALL grow up and move away to college and become insufferable smart-asses the first time they came home for Christmas break. Having another baby doesn't stop time -- I suspect it actually makes it go FASTER. And I don't want it to.
Within reason (don't worry, I'm not going to be one of those "TREASURE EVERY MOMENT" people), I want to be PRESENT for Felicity in the time I have with her outside of work and everything else. I want her to feel my undivided attention and love all the time. I want this special, singular bond I feel with her to be...IT for me. Sort of like my marriage. I have one husband and one child (let's not even get into the pets), and I feel complete. I feel at risk of overextending myself if I had more people to love and tend to, even though I know I would get love and fulfillment back from them, too.
I don't mean to discount the fact that a second child would, inevitably, be as loved as Felicity has been and of course once he/she was here, we would wonder how we survived without that particular child in our family, too. In fact, that's what gives me a kernel of doubt now and then (imagine if my parents had stopped before having ME, after all) -- but that, too, is a slippery slope because you could say that for an infinite number of children.
Look, it's not as though the hard times have meant that I loved Felicity or motherhood any less. All of the joys have outweighed the toughness by an infinite degree. So maybe I'm being unfair to the hypothetical second child in assuming so much about having another would be subtraction instead of addition. And, full disclosure, I was reticent about having children AT ALL for fear of not being able to handle this kind of stuff -- yet we did it, and now it's unfathomable to think about my life without Felicity (yes, yes, all those child-proselytizers from back then -- YOU TOLD ME SO, YOU WERE RIGHT). I am sure that well-meaning strangers who like to comment on family size would cluck at me and say that we should just go for it, it will be fine, and second babies are always SO EASY (ha ha -- I know a number of second babies who have been anything BUT easy, so don't even try that on me).
And sometimes I berate myself for not just...well, sort of for not just being like everyone else. For not simply knowing what I want my family to look like and going for it, for not simply taking a leap of faith and adding to our family while we're still presumably able (though sometimes I think of Elaine on Seinfeld saying, "I should have a baby? Why? Because I CAN?"). Sometimes I wonder if the more...I don't know, the more generous, open-hearted, faithful thing to do would be to forget all my concerns and welcome in all the children that are meant to be mine.
Except, maybe that's just it. Maybe it's that I DO know what I want my family to look like, and it already looks that way. Maybe it's that I DO feel like I have been open to what God has in store for me, and I have accepted what has come (Felicity!) with love and surrender. And I feel like if I were meant to have more, I wouldn't HAVE all these thoughts and feelings. I would be ABLE to just go for it. But that's not how I feel. And it's not what that voice TOLD me I should do (not that I think God was speaking to me or anything -- but my intuition or whatever it was REALLY MEANT IT when it woke me up to tell me that, and the more I've thought about it, the more comfortable I've become -- it's when I think about everyone ELSE and what they want/expect/do that I worry that I'm not doing the right thing).
The fact remains that I love what life with Felicity is like now and what it looks like in the future. We can do so many things together, our little triumvirate. We can explore the world, have infinite adventures, have special quiet times together. We can nurture whatever talents she has without regard to cost or scheduling constraints. I can savor every minute that I am present with my daughter. I can spend all my maternal energy on her and still have energy left for ME, for the things I want to do and for the things I have to do.
Inevitably, people who decide to have a single child will be accused, at some time, by someone, of being selfish. If it's selfish to have the feelings that I do, and to base a MASSIVE decision on how it will affect me (emotionally, socially, professionally, parentally, maritally, physically), then fine, I am selfish. And I'm going to take my selfish self and my one perfect, cherished daughter to the playground when she wakes up from her nap.
